send this page
government
about us
newsrack
 
perspective
forums
subscribe
support
page 1
rockies
opinion
beyond
in-depth
page 2
community
environment
politics
economy
more
workrooms
contact us




The Western Charter Project examines Western values and regional policy issues, and sponsors portions of Headwaters News


Past Perspectives:

Jan. 23:
Economist Tom Power and the West's Post-Cowboy Economy

Jan. 30:
Forest Service learned little from 30 years of controversy on Montana forest.


     
| |
 
This week: Feb. 6, 2002
Court-ordered compassion
 
A growing Hispanic population is exerting its influence on communities, economies and culture throughout the region, and in Idaho, which is not notorious for its tolerance, the changes may be starting from a state appeals court bench.

Idaho's first Hispanic judge a tribute to the man and the state

By Stephen J. Lyons
for Headwaters News

When Idaho Gov. Dirk Kempthorne appointed Third District Judge Sergio A. Gutierrez to the Idaho Court of Appeals this month, it was a "first" for both the Mexican-born Gutierrez and the Gem State.

The 47-year-old judge and the state that has been, at times, dragged unwillingly to the trough of diversity, have become partners in shaping a new vision for the region.

It's a vision and partnership Idaho needs if it has any change of shaking off the damaging effects of Ruby Ridge, the Aryan Nations and many other anti-diversity public relations nightmares.

Gutierrez is the first and only Hispanic judge in Idaho's history, a fact noted during his first judicial appointment in 1993 by then-Gov. Cecil Andrus, and a fact that surfaced again with his appointment to the Idaho Court of Appeals.

This is no ordinary appointment. Sergio Gutierrez's rise to the Appeals Court is the culmination of a journey that began in poverty in Mexico and, on paper at least, should never have succeeded.

The story is not finished, of course. Many expect Gutierrez to eventually occupy a seat on the Idaho Supreme Court. In the meantime, supporters expect Gutierrez to add compassion to the three-member appellate court.

"When I see folks who have a lot to contribute, I am looking through my own window," Gutierrez told me. "Their window is poverty and survival. And the laws in our criminal justice system have not given us the tools to work with women, men and young adults."

As reported by Idaho Statesman columnist Dan Popkey, Canyon County Public Defender Scott Fouser said of Gutierrez, "He has a cultural understanding most of us lack. When he talks to Hispanic defendants about what´s going on in their lives, he´s looking for things that a lot of us won´t see and might not consider significant."

Still, this is not simply a story of one Mexican man's journey from immigration through assimilation to success. The judge's story is uniquely American -- perhaps the same as our parents', or our grandparents'.

In the cities, towns and new barrios of southwestern Idaho, America remains the land of opportunities, and some Hispanics are climbing the economic and political rungs of power. But not all and not easily. If you can make it as a minority in Idaho, you can make it anywhere.

(more)


Have an opinion? Post it now.
Click here to log in to our Forum. Or click here if you haven't yet registered.



click here for a printer-friendly version


| |


Hispanic tide is rising across West

By Greg Lakes, editor
Headwaters News
Feb. 6, 2002

The influx of Hispanics into the West poses the most dramatic demographic changes in the region in a century.

Throughout the Mountain West, companies, communities and regional economies have come to depend on immigrant labor, both legal and otherwise.

Particularly since the 1986 Immigration Reform and Control Act, workers have spilled across the border, mostly from Mexico, but also from other Latin American countries.

Mainly they were content to fill the unskilled jobs others wouldn't, and authorities were content to look the other way.

Now, the numbers have grown into a massive demographic force that promises to change the face of the region's culture, politics and economy.

Utah officials estimate there are 30,000 undocumented workers in their state; others guess there as many as 20 million in the U.S. No one has tried to calculate how much they contribute to the state or national economy, but the Mexican government figures they send home $9 billion each year -- after food, housing and other essentials are bought in the U.S.

In Utah, alone, the number of Hispanics rose from 84,597 to 201,559, not counting those the census workers didn't count. Some Utah communities are one-fifth Hispanic; one, Wendover, on the state's western edge, is two-thirds Hispanic.

And with the numbers, Hispanics' clout is growing. Advocates have staged at least two demonstrations in Salt Lake City calling for unions for undocumented workers, and for changes in immigration laws that recognize the reality and necessity of illegal immigrants' labor.

Hispanics offer a huge market, both for U.S. companies and Mexican retailers. Some estimates put Hispanic buying power in the U.S. at $450 billion a year. Hispanic businesses catering to Hispanic tastes have become integral parts of small-business-driven economies in Idaho, Utah, Arizona and New Mexico.

In an possible spillover effect, Corona beer, a product of Mexico, has become the best-selling import in the U.S., and its parent company will build a malting plant in the middle of Idaho's barley country. The malt will be shipped by rail to breweries in Mexico.

Assimilation has not always been fast or smooth. Arizona lawmakers finally agreed, under threat of court order, to boost funding for English-learner classes -- mostly kids of Hispanic families for whom English is a second language.

But as of early January, lawmakers had yet to carry through, and one public-interest lawyer was threatening a suit to deny the state its federal highway funds until they complied.

In New Mexico, a judge rejected a suit by a community activist who wanted new congressional districts to include one with a clear Hispanic majority. The suit unsuccessfully argued that New Mexico is 42 percent Hispanic, and Hispanics have a unique culture, language and history that qualifies them as a unique voting bloc.

A sweep of Salt Lake City airport workers in mid-December resulted in the arrests of 69 workers. Federal agents called it an anti-terrorist move; Salt Lake Mayor Rocky Anderson called it an act of racial bias that tore apart local families.

And at the end of December, the Idaho Legislature broke years of deadlock and approved a minimum wage for most farm workers. Although the bill was seen as largely symbolic, Idaho became the 10th state with a minimum farm wage, and extended the $5.15 federal minimum to as many as 33,000 mainly Hispanic farm workers.

Meanwhile, the recession has hit Hispanics particularly hard. Low-skill jobs, plentiful during the boom of the '90s, are waning with the economy. One national study predicted that a recovery will reach Hispanic workers last, perhaps not until well into 2004.

For counterpoint, one economist is predicting that Alberta will see an influx of Hispanic and Asian immigrants, and while relations may be prickly at first, Albertans will quickly realize the necessity. The provincial work force is aging, and the resident birth rate is too low to provide enough workers to pay for retirees' social services. The provincial economy, and those retirees' golden years, will depend on importing enough workers.



Have an opinion? Post it now.
Click here to log in to our Forum. Or click here if you haven't yet registered.


| |

click here for a printer-friendly version

 
Related
stories

Alberta's economy will rely on immigrants, expert says.
Edmonton Journal; Feb. 5

Authorities often willing to overlook Utah's illegal workers.
Salt Lake Tribune;
Jan. 27

Latino workers rally for unions.
Salt Lake Tribune;
Jan. 27

Hispanics may not feel economic recovery until 2004.
Arizona Republic;
Jan. 25

Straight to the source: Hispanics and the Current Economic Downturn: Will The Receding Tide Sink Hispanics? With related reports.

Mexican firms cater to U.S. Latino markets.
Deseret News;
Jan. 22

Former Aryan Nations headquarters given to Idaho college.
Spokesman-Review;
Jan. 22

Arizona governor to pitch electricity sales to Mexico.
Arizona Republic;
Jan. 17

Arizona might lose highway funds if it doesn't boost English funding.
Arizona Republic;
Jan. 9

Mexican brewery to build malt plant in Idaho Falls.
Idaho Falls Post Register;
Jan 8

New Mexico judge rejects Hispanic congressional district.
Santa Fe New Mexican; Jan. 3

Idaho's farm-worker wage takes effect.
Idaho Falls Post-Register (AP);
Dec. 31

Opinion

Call for Hispanic workers' Olympic strike set to fizzle.
Deseret News;
Dec. 27


Headwaters News is a project of the Center for the Rocky Mountain West at the University of Montana.