send this page
government
about us
newsrack
 
perspective
forums
subscribe
support
page 1
rockies
opinion
beyond
in-depth
page 2
community
environment
politics
economy
more
workrooms
contact us

Past Perspectives:

Jan. 23:
Economist Tom Power and the West's Post-Cowboy Economy

Jan. 30:
Forest Service learned little from 30 years of controversy on Montana forest.

Feb. 6
Idaho's newest judge illustrates the rising influence of Hispanics.

Feb. 13
Utah's newest monument proposal could be a chance to mend political fences.

Feb. 20
Collaboration and consensus emerge as new ways to manage public lands.

Feb. 27
Montana's Rock Creek Mine would undercut wilderness.

March 6
The rural West's economic development depends on the value of its amenities.

March 13
The guru of intensive grazing says Western ranges will recover better with cattle grazing.

March 20
Rural Western economies haven't faded with the timber industry, they've grown on the strength of forest amenities.

March 27
Stewardship contracts give National Forest rangers the latitude to fix the forest.

April 3
Grand Canyon's seeps and springs are fed by irreplaceable ground water.


 


     
| |
 
This week: April 10, 2002
The price of protection
 
B.C. government's promised austerity cuts environmental agencies, programs

Liberals' 'New Era' could be beginning of the end for some ecosystems

By Jeff Gailus
for Headwaters News


When it comes to the environment, British Columbia’s Liberal government makes George W. Bush’s Republicans look like died-in-the-wool conservationists.

Since routing the New Democrats last May, Liberal leader Gordon Campbell has slashed budgets, eradicated government jobs, eliminated regulations, and privatized services in what one senior policy analyst has called "a recipe for environmental disaster."

"Unprecedented cuts to the ministries responsible for environmental protection jeopardize the natural beauty and diversity of life that are a source of pride and joy for so many B.C. residents," says David Boyd, a senior associate with the University of Victoria's Eco-Research Chair in Environmental Law and Policy, and an adjunct professor in the School of Resource and Environmental Management at Simon Fraser University.

"In the span of a few short years, British Columbia has gone from a national centre of environmental excellence and innovation to a laggard on par with Ontario, Canada's most polluted province and home of the Walkerton tainted water disaster," he said.

A lagging economy and a series of scandals, including the police investigation and subsequent conviction of then-Premier Glen Clark for awarding a conditional casino license to a neighbor, allowed B.C.’s Liberals to snap up 76 of 79 seats in the province’s Legislature, ending 10 years of NDP rule and introducing a "we’ll do whatever we want" attitude, second only to that displayed by Alberta’s Progressive Conservative government.

The Liberals won on a "New Era" platform of "vision, imagination, hope and prosperity." But a projected deficit of $10 billion (Canadian) in the next four years – largely a result of its own tax cuts – inspired the Liberals to slash the budget, decimating the ministries and departments responsible for environmental protection.

Cuts to the Ministry of Water, Land and Air, and the Ministry of Sustainable Resource Management range from 30 percent to 40 percent. These cuts are on top of the 35 percent that was cut from the environment budget during Glen Clark’s reign. In total, B.C.'s environment budget has dropped 60 to 70 percent in less than a decade.


"There were never enough staff nor adequate policies and procedures to do an effective job of protecting critical habitats in our forests. Now, government intends to take away more staff from this function."

-- Tom Burgess, retired provincial biologist


Budget cuts almost always translate into fewer jobs. The three ministries responsible for environmental protection in B.C. will lose a total of 2,382 employees. The Ministry of Water, Land and Air will lose 401 of 1,298 employees (31 percent), the Ministry of Sustainable Resource Development will lose 548 of 1,508 ( 36 percent), and the Ministry of Forests will lose 1,433 of 4,061 (35 percent).

These cuts will affect everything from interpretation in parks to identifying and protecting habitat for endangered species like the woodland caribou.

"There will be only 225 staff left for the entire province, charged with the responsibility of maintaining fish and wildlife populations and their habitats and providing us with various opportunities to enjoy them," wrote retired provincial biologist Tom Burgess, in a six-page report he compiled from government sources.

True to their words – Liberal politicians pledged to "do away with constraints on economic development," "eliminate regulations to facilitate industry competitiveness," and "approve projects in a more timely, cost-effective and certain fashion" – the Liberal government also has embarked on a program of deregulation and privatization that will put the integrity of B.C.’s environment at serious risk.

According to Boyd, one-third of the regulations protecting B.C.’s air, water, forests, and wildlife will be removed, and the environmental assessment process, which ensures commercial and industrial activities do not unduly harm the natural environment, will be "streamlined."

In the wake of intensifying public criticism, Minister of Water, Land and Air Protection Joyce Murray said the government had no choice but to implement its downsizing program.

(more)

Have an opinion? Join the discussion in this week's forum.

Or click here to view all our forums.


click here for a printer-friendly version of this column


| |


B.C. Liberals take on native bands, doctors and a widening budget chasm

By Greg Lakes, editor
Headwaters News
April 10, 2002

Premier Gordon Campbell's Liberal government has had its hands full since it took over from the previous and hugely unpopular New Democrats.

Campbell and company vowed to cut costs, red tape and government largesse, and to reverse B.C.'s economic slide. It's been a rare week without a crisis since.

A round of tax cuts were followed by predictions of a $4.4 million deficit. The Liberals responded with plans to raise sales and cigarette taxes, a violation of campaign promises.

Campbell ordered a review of government contracts with doctors, college employees and health-care workers, and rolled back locked-in salaries.

Unions have recently launched a national ad campaign accusing Campbell of being untrustworthy and urging investors to shy away from B.C.

Cambell's response was that salary cuts merely scaled back costs to reasonable levels for "the highest-paid nurses in the country, the second-highest-paid teachers in the country or health-care workers that are paid 30 percent more than the national average."

Meanwhile, the economy continues to take a beating from the U.S. tariffs on softwood lumber imports. Canadian negotiators last month walked away from demands they deemed unreasonable and the U.S. set a 29 percent duty to take effect in May.

The interim tariff has already cost B.C. companies 15,000 jobs, and although some industry spokesman have called for a corresponding decrease in the price of crown lumber, most observers' forecasts are gloomy, at best.

Campbell's Liberals inherited an Indian claims stalemate and has fanned the simmering issue into a hot debate. They campaigned on a promise to solicit public input on treaty negotiations and drafted a mail-in referendum that has drawn criticism from a variety of quarters.

Officials say the referendum is an exercise in direct democracy, but critics call it a mockery guaranteed to prevent any agreement for generations.

Some 51 B.C. Indian bands claim almost all of the province as their ancestral lands, and a decade and $500 million of negotiations has produced no agreement.

The referendum includes eight questions that reflect government positions on bargaining points, including whether to phase out tax exemptions for natives; refuse to expropriate private property for settlements; restrict Indian self-government to the same powers as a city; let everyone hunt, fish and recreate on Crown land; make parks open to all British Columbians; and apply provincial environmental standards to native lands.

Tribal leaders and advocates have alleged the questions are loaded, the language is leading and some of the authority in question is beyond the scope of the provincial government.

And government officials say that while they'll heed a majority of yes answers, they'll not be bound by a negative vote.

One of the government's latest developments is a plan to allow oil and gas drilling off B.C.'s coast. Untapped reserves are thought to be approximately 10 billion barrels of oil and 26 trillion cubic feet of natural gas, which would be more than double the deposits off the Newfoundland coast.

B.C. imposed a moratorium on offshore drilling in the 1950s, lifted it for a a few years to allow exploration in the late 1960s, and reimposed it in 1972.

Campbell said lifting the moratorium is a priority for his administration.

He also said he'll encourage coalbed methane development throughout B.C. and further development of the Ladyfern field in the province's northeast corner, all of which could combine to make B.C. a major energy producer.

But the Haida Nation has filed suit with the Supreme Court, asking to be recognized as sole owner of the Queen Charlotte Islands and all the oil beneath.


Have an opinion? Join the discussion in this week's forum.

Or click here to view all our forums.


click here for a printer-friendly version of this column


| |

 
Related stories
B.C. unions take fight to Ontario
Vancouver Sun;
April 9

Canada deserves an endangered species bill
Globe and Mail;
April 08

B.C. close to permitting offshore drilling
National Post;
April 08

B.C. city rated best in Northwest for residents' lifestyle, longevity
Vancouver Sun;
April 04

Critics flay B.C. mail referendum on native claims
Globe and Mail;
April 03

B.C. towns prepare for mill closures, economic ills.
Vancouver Sun;
Mar. 26

B.C. industry wants lower stumpage rates to compensate for U.S. tariff.
National Post;
Mar. 25

Farm runoff elevates B.C.'s Fraser River to list of most endangered.
Vancouver Sun;
March 19

Report says global warming has altered B.C. habitats.
Vancouver Sun;
March 15

B.C. tribe lays substantial claim to islands off northern coast
Vancouver Sun;
March 8

B.C. government to renege on doctors' pay.
Vancouver Sun;
March 6


B.C. budget cuts not enough to stem flood of red ink
Globe and Mail;
Feb. 20


Opinion

Participation is key to opposition of B.C. native referendum
Vancouver Sun;
April 08

B.C.'s Indian referendum makes settlements even more unlikely
Edmonton Journal;
April 04

B.C. ministers' assault on U.S. trade policies clashes with reality
Vancouver Sun;
Mar. 29

Unyielding positions will never settle B.C. native claims.

Vancouver Sun;
March 18

Ottawa must give provinces more leeway on health care.
Vancouver Sun;
Jan. 07


Headwaters News is a project of the Center for the Rocky Mountain West at the University of Montana.