Headwaters Home
subscribe
Page 1
contact us
search
Headwaters Perspective Headwaters News engages our readers in a different issue every other week.

We encourage you to send us your comments. Your email must contain your name.
   
 
Send this page
to a friend or colleague

Read past Perspectives

Read the Interior Secretaries series


Related stories:
     


Phoenix officials consider adding commuter rail to transit plans Arizona Republic; Oct. 27 

Realtors may have won the war on housing 'bubble'
New York Times; 10/23/05

Boise's $60 million revitalization project poised to open
Idaho Statesman; 10/23/2005

Phoenix downtown could be wireless by next summer
Arizona Republic; 09/26/2005

Durango infill standards protect current residents
Durango Herald; 09/25/2005

Development along Denver transit route breaks ground
Denver Rocky Mountain News; 08/10/2005

Board issues infill injunction for Montana city
Missoulian; 07/29/2005

Arizona light-rail system gets $75 million federal boost
Phoenix Business Journal; 12/09/2004

Commuters want to live near light rail lines in big cities
USA Today; 11/09/2004

Editorials

Does Growth Change the People or the Place?
New West; 10/21/05



 

     
Western Perspective is sponsored by:

Hewlett

CRMW logo
Western Perspective Analysis
Western cities could outgrow their identity
By Daniel Berger, assistant editor
Headwaters News
Oct. 27, 2005

Get up, eat breakfast, give the dog a scratch and a treat, go to work.

My routine is just like that of many employed adults in America. But where the daily routine takes a marked turn is when I stop by a hidden fishing hole on the west edge of town for a couple hours after work to cast to hefty, healthy, wild trout sipping bugs from the surface of a relatively clean, free-flowing river.

The livability, or quality of life, of our cities, as Daniel Kemmis writes in this week's Western Perspective, is crucial to the preservation and progress of the West as a region, and our region's immersion into a global society.

Many cities and towns can claim they are "livable." My home town of Philadelphia is often called livable because houses are cheaper and amenities easier to reach compared to the other regional cities.

But the West offers a unique brand of livability. Our recent economic growth is fueled by the desire by many to move here for the open spaces, both the smaller ones that border our towns and the wider ones that stretch across our states.

Losing open space has become a crucial issue for many towns and urban areas in the West simply because we still have that open space to lose. Not that open space is a new thing in the West.

Our wild and undeveloped lands have always been--and one can argue--still are, the resource base that provides the West a place in the global village. But it's our cities that are going to keep us there.

If it is our effort to preserve that which uniquely makes our cities livable, then what are we doing toward that end? And what are the stumbling blocks to come along the way?

There are certain universal needs that emerge whenever a city is formed or grows. They include housing, transportation, access to amenities, a clean and healthful environment, and an allowance for the economy to grow.

These aren't necessarily unique to the cities in our region, but because we're younger than most other cities, we can take the lessons of others to heart when planning our light rails, downtown growth and redevelopment. Light rail is attracting supporters across the country, especially as traffic congestion and gas prices increase.

Phoenix, Denver and Salt Lake City all have growing light rail systems. And these cities are finding that, not only does the system move people around more effectively, light rail stations are also becoming driving forces behind commercial and residential development . Build a station and the townhouses and offices follow.

Kemmis also calls for the promotion of downtown living, which is a shift from the way cities are built across this country. Cars and the desire for larger homes have pushed our cities outward, creating sprawl, a primary threat to the open spaces that border our towns. Light rail and downtown redevelopment will help pull people back toward a center. Boise just opened a new downtown mall, and condos are selling in downtown Salt Lake City before they are even built.

Installing wireless Internet access is another feature cities such as Phoenix and Colorado Springs are using to pull people back downtown.

The trick in revitalizing downtowns will be to properly manage traffic, mix affordable housing among the luxury places and find a way to balance sprawl with infill, a challenge that has plagued big cities and small towns alike. The sprawl-versus-infill debate comes down to what citizens find tolerable.

Determining what is tolerable infill has often led to squabbles between homeowners, city officials and developers in places such as Missoula and Durango. In other cities, such as Salt Lake City, inaction has allowed huge new houses to sprout up haphazardly in older neighborhoods with more modest homes. After years of debate, Boise finally passed a slate of new infill laws.

Sprawl, in turn, affects almost every urban area, from the small ski town to the mega-metropolis.

This sprawl-versus-infill debate is closely tied to the housing market, which has provided a boom for many in several Western towns and cities, including developers and the little old lady next door, who may have sold her home for hundreds of thousands of dollars more than for which it was purchased. The boom and the creative mortgages now offered have allowed many more people to own homes, but many low-income people remain priced out of the market.

Though as much a regional issue as an urban one, illegal immigration and education will also continue to be major factors shaping the West. Without a sustainable, efficient and just way to handle the influx of mostly Latino immigrants and the education of all of our kids, regardless of their race or where they live, the West won't make it in a global world.

 
Headwaters News is a project of the
Center for the Rocky Mountain West
at the University of Montana.
 


Daniel Kemmis
writes
a bi-monthly column for Headwaters News that focuses issues common to the Rocky Mountain States.


Daniel Kemmis is a Senior Fellow at the Center for the Rocky Mountain West at The University of Montana.

He is the former Mayor of Missoula, Montana, and a former Speaker and Minority Leader of the Montana House of Representatives.

Mr. Kemmis is the author of three books: Community and The Politics of Place; The Good City and the Good Life; and This Sovereign Land: A New Vision for Governing the West.

In 1998, the Center of the American West awarded him the Wallace Stegner Prize for sustained contribution to the cultural identity of the West.

In 2002, This Sovereign Land was the top choice for the Interior Department's Executive Forum Speaker Series.

comment on this column